Upon exiting the theater after my first viewing of Star Trek: Into Darkness, I was fairly certain that there would be absolutely no point in seeing any other movie for the rest of the summer, convinced I had already seen the best one. While purists of the original series might be experiencing mental short-circuits at some of the turns Into Darkness dared to make, as a sci-fi piece Into Darkness is one of the finest that the genre has produced in recent years, with or without the Star Trek title. Purist readers (you know who you are): remember what alternative universe means. Things can be different. Moving on.
Into Darkness moves seamlessly and rhythmically from mood to mood, gliding from comical to heart-pounding to melancholy. Kirk's violation of the Prime Directive leaves a primitive tribe in a state of comical confusion, and then, with no transition or explanation, we're shown how far into darkness and depravity a man will go to save his dying daughter. This is where the story really takes off and sets up the theme of the movie: the needs of many vs. the needs of the few, and the true meaning of sacrifice.
With all the main characters already well-established, Into Darkness doesn't waste too much time with expository cutscenes or dialogue except with the antagonist Harrison. Otherwise the audience is thrown right into the story with familiar knowledge of all the returning characters. Although some of Spock's decisions might surprise Kirk, they're not really surprising to the audience, and likewise with Spock's surprise at some of Kirk's decisions. The friendship between the two is still young and developing, but at least at the start of the movie they like each other, which is an improvement.
Kirk, Spock, Uhura, Scotty, Dr. McCoy, Chekhov, and the rest of the Enterprise crew are all as good as they were last time, but the real show-stealer here is John Harrison, ingeniously played by Benedict Cumberbatch. While it's certainly no spoiler to reveal that he is in fact the villain (shocking!), that knowledge somehow didn't prevent me from occasionally wondering if he might be just misunderstood. This is especially impressive when one considers that he enters the movie as a terrorist who first manipulates a desperate man into setting off an explosive, and then flies a small aircraft right up to Starfleet Headquarters and proceeds to fire upon a gathering of officers, taking the life of one in particular. And yet despite these introductions, his mysterious demeanor demands investigation and intrigue, maybe even fleeting sympathy. He has believable motives that almost justify his heartless extremism, and the course of the story reveals that he is not the only heartless villain at play; the Enterprise is merely caught in the middle.
Harrison's manner is regal, edgy, and cold. He seems both tigerish and serpentine, yet undeniably admirable. Whether supremely evil or just driven to extreme measures by strong loyalty, he commands respect but also, caution. While his motives can be guessed at, they are not fully revealed until the movie's third and most heart-racing act, where momentum has built to warp-speed, and the victory or defeat of the Enterprise is at a breaking point. And someone's head is at breaking point.
Paramount to a great movie is a great villain, and Into Darkness has a great villain. Although his origins are based on a previous Star Trek nemesis, Cumberbatch takes the character in an entirely new direction, leaving only a few basic elements of his history to resemble the previous portrayal of the character. Truthfully, the moment when "Harrison" reveals his true identity, there was a sharp intake of breath all across the theater, and I applaud the writers for not giving it away too early or giving too many hints to spoil that surprise.
One of the most delightful things about Into Darkness besides its compelling plot, is how it pays homage to the original series and gives allusions to some of the most famous moments of the vintage Star Trek movies, without being too obvious. For example, Dr. McCoy casually mentions a Gorn, tossing a bone to a classic moment in the original series. Dr. Marcus mentions Nurse Chapell, who never features onscreen, but would be well-known to a real Trekkie. As would the mention of a tribble, the true identity of officer Carol, and so on. Other moments deliberately play off of well-known scenes, but steer in an opposite direction. This is a parallel universe after all, so no one is bound by needing to remake anything-- things can play out in any variety of ways. For that reason, I toyed back and forth with how I felt about the appearance of Nimoy-Spock. In some ways it seemed to be just a memo to the Trekkies that this is still Star Trek. In other ways it seemed to serve as a brief reminder of what happened in that Spock's universe when they were in a similar situation, so as to prep the audience for what occurs shortly thereafter to the current Enterprise.
With a sterling plot, excellent twists, well-timed comic levity, sweeping cinematography and solid performances throughout, it can be honestly stated that the only flaws to this film are the overuse of solar flare effects, and the superfluous shot of Carol in her underwear. Apparently a lot of Trekkies took issue with the latter, and everyone else with the former. These are minor flaws in an otherwise shining piece of science fiction entertainment. Star Trek Into Darkness does justice to its genre and its legacy, at least as good if not better than The Wrath of Khan.
Whoops!
Spoiler...
A whimsical collection of reviews, essays, and pieces on the film arts from an analytical amateur movie critic. a.k.a. ramblings
Showing posts with label villain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label villain. Show all posts
Thursday, October 24, 2013
Star Trek: Into Darkness
Labels:
character analysis,
review,
sci-fi,
villain
Monday, March 11, 2013
Welcome Back Mr. Bond
I've never been a fan of James Bond really, but Casino Royale changed that for me. Ever since Daniel Craig put on the tux, 007 has been more interesting, more compelling, and just better in general. While the follow-up to Casino Royale was horribly disappointing, Bond's return in Skyfall comes back with such a bang, it may well be one of the best Bond movies ever.
One of the most compelling aspects of Skyfall was the side of James Bond that has to this point never been seen before. In the past, Bond may occasionally meet with a nefarious villain or world-scale conflict, but he remains suave, debonair, and usually cocky to the end. Not so now. 007 has suffered a hit, and it's a major one. For the first time ever, Bond doesn't seem invincible-- he seems human. Bond has been shaken and stirred by four life-changing words; "take the bloody shot."
"Agent down."
Bond spends the next few months pretending to be dead and allowing everyone to believe that he is. What is so interesting is how this emotionally affects him. When he returns, he doesn't shoot straight and he can't pass his psychological or physical exam, but he has a dangerous look in his eye. Something in him truly has died, and something else has awakened. While we don't learn much about Bond's past, we learn enough to understand just a little, why he became James Bond. While Skyfall has its elements of global ramifications pending Bond's success or failure, Skyfall is on most levels, personal.
M, always masterfully portrayed by Dame Judi Dench, is often forced to make difficult judgement calls that sacrifice a few for the good of many. It was such a judgement call that left James Bond for dead, but he isn't the first to suffer from one of M's judgement calls. And a less loyal victim has returned to make M, and many MI6 agents around the world, suffer for her choices. Global ramifications: agents around the world are being exposed and executed. Personal vendetta: it was M's judgement call that turned a loyal agent into a sadistic lunatic who doesn't care how many lives it takes, he will have his revenge on M.
The mastermind villain here is Silva, diabolically played by Javier Bardem (a man who has a knack for playing psychopathic evildoers with preposterous hair-- see No Country for Old Men). Of all the characters that have been introduced into the new Bond franchise, from M to Q to Miss Moneypenny, Silva can be adequately praised as being a villain for the Bond ages. What I mean is, Bond villains have ranged from being criminal masterminds over global plots, to the downright comic bookish ones. Really, the most consistent characters throughout the many adaptations of Bond have been the women, but that's another issue altogether. The point is, the character of Silva feels very much like he could have been the star of a comic book movie adaptation (think the Joker) with his maniacal and titanic plots, but he's also frighteningly believable. Once the pet of M16, Silva was sacrificed for the greater good, and he has never forgotten it. Not that this makes him sympathetic by any means, merely realistic. His purpose isn't to take over the world, or to watch it burn, he wants M to watch her agents burn. His purpose is personal, vengeful, and believable.
Skyfall presents a realistic-enough scenario with believable ramifications, which is part of what makes it unique and strong to itself. What I mean is this: let's say that somehow a list of internationally assigned agents was leaked and put on YouTube. Is there really any doubt that the consequences would be any different than those portrayed onscreen? Unlikely. While at first glance the temptation is to write off the executed agents as casualties of war who knew the risks, the true implications are far deeper. In the Bond world at least, M16 is one of the greatest opponents of evil in the world, therefore the loss of agents across the globe not only means tragic loss of life, it undercuts MI6's ability to keep the forces of evil at bay.
Another aspect of Skyfall that made the movie unique to itself, is how the story implies the cost of being an agent for good. While previous Bond film Goldeneye had some similarities to the base plot of Skyfall in its portrayal of the emotional and psychological implications of being a surviving "casualty", Skyfall really takes it to a new level. First, even James Bond himself is not untouchable; he is every bit as expendable as any other agent, and every bit as vulnerable. Not even 007 can hear the words "take the bloody shot", feel the bullet rip through his body, and not be affected. At no point does Skyfall try to indicate that Bond's reluctance to be trusting again is a sign of weakness, or that a better agent might have done differently. M might pass herself off as being cold and uncaring, but her regrets are evident.
Some critics have complained that Skyfall lacked a thick enough plot to be worthy of 007. Others have hailed it as one of the finest Bond movies yet. I would fall on the latter side of this argument. While it's true that Skyfall's main plot vehicle does not seem globally relevant, the implications are larger than they are presented as. And furthermore the personal revenge agenda adds an element of tension the absence of which would have rendered the entire film boring.Personal preferences on content aside (because I just have no stomach for Bond's womanizing ways), in terms of depth I rank Skyfall among the highest of the 007 movies.
One of the most compelling aspects of Skyfall was the side of James Bond that has to this point never been seen before. In the past, Bond may occasionally meet with a nefarious villain or world-scale conflict, but he remains suave, debonair, and usually cocky to the end. Not so now. 007 has suffered a hit, and it's a major one. For the first time ever, Bond doesn't seem invincible-- he seems human. Bond has been shaken and stirred by four life-changing words; "take the bloody shot."
"Agent down."
Bond spends the next few months pretending to be dead and allowing everyone to believe that he is. What is so interesting is how this emotionally affects him. When he returns, he doesn't shoot straight and he can't pass his psychological or physical exam, but he has a dangerous look in his eye. Something in him truly has died, and something else has awakened. While we don't learn much about Bond's past, we learn enough to understand just a little, why he became James Bond. While Skyfall has its elements of global ramifications pending Bond's success or failure, Skyfall is on most levels, personal.
M, always masterfully portrayed by Dame Judi Dench, is often forced to make difficult judgement calls that sacrifice a few for the good of many. It was such a judgement call that left James Bond for dead, but he isn't the first to suffer from one of M's judgement calls. And a less loyal victim has returned to make M, and many MI6 agents around the world, suffer for her choices. Global ramifications: agents around the world are being exposed and executed. Personal vendetta: it was M's judgement call that turned a loyal agent into a sadistic lunatic who doesn't care how many lives it takes, he will have his revenge on M.
The mastermind villain here is Silva, diabolically played by Javier Bardem (a man who has a knack for playing psychopathic evildoers with preposterous hair-- see No Country for Old Men). Of all the characters that have been introduced into the new Bond franchise, from M to Q to Miss Moneypenny, Silva can be adequately praised as being a villain for the Bond ages. What I mean is, Bond villains have ranged from being criminal masterminds over global plots, to the downright comic bookish ones. Really, the most consistent characters throughout the many adaptations of Bond have been the women, but that's another issue altogether. The point is, the character of Silva feels very much like he could have been the star of a comic book movie adaptation (think the Joker) with his maniacal and titanic plots, but he's also frighteningly believable. Once the pet of M16, Silva was sacrificed for the greater good, and he has never forgotten it. Not that this makes him sympathetic by any means, merely realistic. His purpose isn't to take over the world, or to watch it burn, he wants M to watch her agents burn. His purpose is personal, vengeful, and believable.Skyfall presents a realistic-enough scenario with believable ramifications, which is part of what makes it unique and strong to itself. What I mean is this: let's say that somehow a list of internationally assigned agents was leaked and put on YouTube. Is there really any doubt that the consequences would be any different than those portrayed onscreen? Unlikely. While at first glance the temptation is to write off the executed agents as casualties of war who knew the risks, the true implications are far deeper. In the Bond world at least, M16 is one of the greatest opponents of evil in the world, therefore the loss of agents across the globe not only means tragic loss of life, it undercuts MI6's ability to keep the forces of evil at bay.
Another aspect of Skyfall that made the movie unique to itself, is how the story implies the cost of being an agent for good. While previous Bond film Goldeneye had some similarities to the base plot of Skyfall in its portrayal of the emotional and psychological implications of being a surviving "casualty", Skyfall really takes it to a new level. First, even James Bond himself is not untouchable; he is every bit as expendable as any other agent, and every bit as vulnerable. Not even 007 can hear the words "take the bloody shot", feel the bullet rip through his body, and not be affected. At no point does Skyfall try to indicate that Bond's reluctance to be trusting again is a sign of weakness, or that a better agent might have done differently. M might pass herself off as being cold and uncaring, but her regrets are evident.
Some critics have complained that Skyfall lacked a thick enough plot to be worthy of 007. Others have hailed it as one of the finest Bond movies yet. I would fall on the latter side of this argument. While it's true that Skyfall's main plot vehicle does not seem globally relevant, the implications are larger than they are presented as. And furthermore the personal revenge agenda adds an element of tension the absence of which would have rendered the entire film boring.Personal preferences on content aside (because I just have no stomach for Bond's womanizing ways), in terms of depth I rank Skyfall among the highest of the 007 movies.
Tuesday, August 28, 2012
The Man Who was Batman
This is the third installment of my Dark Knight Rises analyses.
When
Batman Begins debuted, it was clear that Bruce was going to be a different kind
of hero. His motivation began as a personal quest to ease his own emotional pain, but those
reasons gradually became greater and larger than himself. In The Dark Knight, Bruce was
shown to be at the top of his game as Gotham's savior, having met his legendary
foe the Joker, and pushing the limits of technology and physical strength
further than they had ever been before. Bruce battled with how far he would go
before crossing the line into becoming a villain himself, often barely
different in his methods and approaches. By the time the film wrapped, he
allowed a villain to be hailed a hero, and took the blame for all the man's
misdeeds himself. In essence, Bruce chose to become in name what he stood
against in his heart. Eight years later, Bruce is weary, physically weaker,
heartbroken, and considerably less resolved to be Gotham's hope. Bruce is now a has-been
hero, no longer jumping from buildings and leaping from aircraft, but a
recluse; shut-up in the confines of his manor with only Alfred for
consolation.
Batman Begins is a perfect origin story. Bruce is seen as a
child, a college student, and finally a man. He grows from one stage to the
next and through his experiences determines to become the Bat Man in order to
take Gotham back from the corrupt powers that have overrun it. In a city so bad
that there is no higher power to
appeal to, Bruce dared to stand alone against the tide of evil and corruption, using
his billionaire funds to equip himself to be mysterious, powerful, swift, and
terrifying to those who stood in his way. Everything from Bruce's martial arts
training to his fancy toys were accounted for and explained in Batman
Begins.
As a sequel, The Dark Knight stands as one of the greatest sequels
ever made. Where Rhas Al Ghul challenged Batman's definition of justice, the
Joker tested Batman's limits. Bruce was once a young idealist who refused to
become an executioner, but how long could he hold to that? Deeper still, what
is the true difference between a hero and a villain, and how far can a hero go
before he becomes a villain? Even Bruce couldn't answer this one, but he found
out the answer before fleeing into darkness for eight years. Now as a worn out,
discouraged, and seeming failure of a hero, the question is whether or not
Bruce will rise again and come to Gotham's rescue one last time.
The Dark Knight Rises is first and foremost, a tale on
perseverance. Bruce is not what he used to be and even his faithful Alfred
declares "You're not Batman anymore!" Bruce knows it. He grapples
with whether or not it is time to don the cape again, even though he doubts
that Batman even exists anymore. Physically, Batman is no match for Bane, and Bruce
is for the first time, struggling financially. But
somewhere between all of this, Bruce realizes that not only is he still the
most able to save Gotham, he is the only one who can. The question then becomes,
will he? The city that demonized him now cries out for his aide, while the only
person that he truly cares about is telling him that he can't. Will
he lose everything or sacrifice it? And will any of it really make any
difference?
Gotham City is exactly the type of place
that seems doomed to continue attracting the world’s most maniacal breeds of
Fausts and Mephistopheles for the rest of time, which raises the question as to
why Batman/Bruce would go to such great lengths to save it. As previously
mentioned, The Dark Knight Rises is a tale on perseverance. It is a story of
plodding onwards in the face of truly overwhelming odds with only the tiniest
glimmer of hope that any victory is even remotely possible. Bruce lies in a pit
with a broken back, watching news reports of Gotham rip itself apart, yet he
musters the courage to crawl out and rise to Gotham’s aide. Why? Because it is the
right thing to do, and it is the hill he has chosen to die on, figuratively speaking. Gotham will not stay saved forever, but Bruce still rises
from his fallen and broken state to give the last that he can before leaving Batman
behind.
When Bruce first became Batman, he knew
the workings of a criminal mind and the complexities of the not-so-simple
nature of right and wrong, yet he was still something of an idealist. His
vision was that his example as a symbol of justice would inspire others to
fight back, and that eventually a legion would rise
to restore Gotham. With very few allies, it seemed a one-sided battle for many years, and
when white knight Harvey Dent turned two-faced, the battle seemed to be losing. Now in the
final showdown, the conflict demands that this be the end of Batman. But before
Bruce leaves Batman behind forever, he chooses a successor who is everything
that Bruce used to be, and more. Gotham will still need saving, but Bruce’s
time has passed. So young Detective Blake is chosen to be Gotham’s next savior.
Like Bruce, he graduated from the school of hard knocks, but unlike Bruce, he
is untainted by it. Blake has a heart of compassion and purity that Bruce no
longer has, if he ever did, and Bruce recognizes that it is time to pass the
mantle off to someone who is still good, and willing to give as much as Bruce did to the cause.
Batman Begins was the start of the story, The Dark Knight was the climax
for Batman, and The Dark Knight Rises seems to be the climax for Gotham, and
the epilogue of the Batman tales. Bruce has been challenged in his notions of
justice and his motives for becoming the Bat Man. He has tested his moral and ethical limits and his emotional strength. He has been forced to ask himself how far he can go before it is too far. Now he has learned endurance. The
Batman trilogy of movies do not necessarily seek to dictate whether or not Bruce
passes these tests, but to posit that rather than doing the best that he could;
he did what was necessary.
Labels:
analysis,
Batman,
Bruce Wayne,
character analysis,
comic book movie,
hero,
review,
The Dark Knight,
The Dark Knight Rises,
villain
Tuesday, July 31, 2012
Bane: Son of Anarchy
The villains of the Christopher Nolan Batman trilogy have each dictated the tone of their respective movies and brought out a new side of Batman himself. Where Rhas Al Ghul became an elegant extremist in the name of justice and balance, the Joker was an agent of chaos with no motive other than turning Gotham around on its head so many times that it would inevitably stab itself in the heart. Everyone knows that the Joker is Batman’s ultimate nemesis, and readers of the books would identify Rhas Al Ghul as the legendary leader of the League of Shadows. Bane is a new kind of villain, and relatively unknown at that, except to avid graphic novel readers. So who is the Bane of Gotham and how does he fit into the Nolan interpretation of the Dark Knight?
Bane
is first and foremost, an anarchist. He is part revolutionary, part dictator,
but never setting himself up as an authority figure in Gotham. Even in the peak
of his success of turning Gotham inside out and letting its heart rot in the
trenches of terror and tyranny, Bane is an embodiment of the spirit of fear. He
“rules” Gotham like a prison where he is the alpha inmate. He is a
prisoner as well, but he builds a kingdom of horror and dread within that
isolated world. His creation is a mockery of democracy, even as he
parades the perverse beauty of equality, toppling the wealthy in the manner of
the French Revolution where Gotham’s rich are the doomed aristocracy.
Well,
spoiler alert for the rest of this review, Bane is an accomplice. Before I come under fire for saying such
a thing, finish reading this bit. There is no denying that Bane is a powerful
leader. As previously stated, he is part revolutionary, part tyrant. In the
engaging opening sequence of the Dark Knight Rises, a very elaborate and grisly
plot unfolds to kidnap a scientist off his plane, involving a rather brilliant
hijacking if it can even be called such. Here we see a brief but clear
demonstration of Bane’s power as a leader when a word to a “brother” convinces
the other to die in the wreckage of a plane. Bane’s rule by fear and illusions
of brotherhood bring to him a following of cowardly and brutish criminals who
blindly follow his merciless lead. All offenses are punishable by death, and
yet they flock to tremble in his shadow.
But
even in his mastery of the power of lawlessness and unquestionable brute
strength, Bane is (almost disappointingly so) not the brains of the operation.
He is the brawn, the passion, and the one who carries out the grand scheme, but
he is not the mastermind. That is not to say that he could not be— he certainly
has the power and despite comic book archetypes equating bulky bodies with low
intellect, Bane is not stupid. But minutes from the credits, his true master
steps forward. He is shortly thereafter disposed of unceremoniously in a manner befitting a
sidekick.
Bane may not have been the brains behind the fall of Gotham, but he did the dirty work is his own brutal way. He may be Talia’s pawn, but make no mistake that she does not keep him a leash—she does not have to. She may the only one who does not fear him, so she releases him to accomplish her purposes in whatever way he sees fit. He is still allowed to be the radical terrorist without any real restrictions on his methods.
Bane may not have been the brains behind the fall of Gotham, but he did the dirty work is his own brutal way. He may be Talia’s pawn, but make no mistake that she does not keep him a leash—she does not have to. She may the only one who does not fear him, so she releases him to accomplish her purposes in whatever way he sees fit. He is still allowed to be the radical terrorist without any real restrictions on his methods.
To be fair, even as the right hand man of the true villainess, he is still a force unleashed, worthy to be feared, even if his personality and speech are somewhat suppressed by his facial apparatus. Tom Hardy does as well as he possibly can to bring Bane to life through expressive voice inflections and wild glances, but at times Bane is hard to understand-- literally. His motives are not fully revealed until the condensed finale, making him less compelling than he could have been as a character. By the time Talia is revealed as the alpha-villain, it is too late to just push Bane aside-- he has been the face of evil for the entire movie! Because of this, his exit was unsatisfying, as is his final showdown with Batman. Throughout the film, the fiend has snapped necks, ruthlessly broken Bruce's back, thrown him into the pit of the earth, gutted Gotham inside-out, trapped hundreds of police officials in a claustrophobic nightmare, and toppled the already unstable ruling powers of Gotham. In return for these heinous misdeeds, Batman punches him in the face. To add insult to the injury of not having a finale-worthy Mano-a-mano confrontation, Batman does not even get to finish Bane himself.
Bane works in a league of his own not to be compared with previous nemeses-- he simply can't be. He is not a perfect villain, but he does well, and he possesses the soul of Gotham adequately enough to be counted a notable adversary. Bane's description of himself as "a necessary evil" sums up quite eloquently his mission and his views. Bane is mysterious, dangerous, and unexpected, but true to his nature and his namesake, is the bane of Gotham and Batman.
bane
[beyn]
Labels:
analysis,
Bane,
Batman,
character analysis,
review,
The Dark Knight,
The Dark Knight Rises,
villain
Tuesday, July 10, 2012
Memoirs of Stargate SG-1
It began one summer with a new friendship. I had met a certain guy who shared my love of science fiction and through the combined efforts of my new fellow nerd and my roommate, I entered into the ten season relationship of Stargate: SG-1. Having grown up on the movie Stargate, I had always been curious about the series spin-off but had been unable to watch the series. Until 2009. One Sunday afternoon, my roommate and I settled down and she put in the first of many discs from her deluxe box set. One episode led to another, and then another. Soon our numbers grew from two to three to six, convening once a week to watch and enjoy together.
I will admit that the pilot episode did not immediately evoke devoted following. The TV-level special effects were dated and unimpressive by 2009 standards—the quality of the special effects seemed to pick up technologically where Star Trek: The Next Generation left off. Still, I was generous with my judgments, allowing that this was a product of late 1990’s television. When the premiere villain Apophis made his grand entrance however, it was more difficult to excuse the campy costumes and overdone makeup. My companions advised me to focus on the story rather than the visual efforts, as they did have a smaller budget in their earlier seasons. Beyond that, the “visual efforts” involved content more suited to an HBO type series. So I suspended judgment despite thinking deep within myself “it’s going to be like this for a few seasons?” I pushed through with the hope that better entertainment lie on the other side of season one. I was right.
As in most TV series, the actors involved took some getting used to in that first season as they settled into their characters. At times I wondered if they were being prompted or reading their lines off a faraway wall. But eventually as the actors became more comfortable with their characters, I became more comfortable with them as well and began developing impressions of each and guessing at their motives, personalities, and destinies. I latched on to Jack O’Neill and his sardonic humor. I sympathized with Daniel Jackson and his quest to rescue his wife from her captivity. Teal’c gained my interest as I pondered his loyalties and dark past. Even Samantha Carter gained my approval once I got past her Princess Diana haircut and frequent tendency to play the exposition fairy with her ridiculous knowledge of… everything (thankfully all these characteristics were toned down as the series went on).
Season two came around and as the story improved, so did the special effects, costumes, and writing. The actors, now comfortable in their roles, carried their parts naturally and effortlessly. Events were now happening that would carry ramifications lasting several seasons or at least revisited multiple times. Sam became host to Tok’ra symbiote Jolinar, Daniel began his long track record of attracting abnormal females, both the formidable and the ridiculous Goa’uld made appearances and reappearances, and Sam’s father Jacob was set up as a returning guest character. Not only did SG-1 have alien threats to deal with, they now fought domestic politics on their home turf, developing strained and cantankerous relationships with the corrupt Senator Kinsey and the hated Maybourne. Finally, the plot was thickening!
One storyline would lead to another and then taper off, birthing a greater arc, or even memorable stand-alone episodes. As the series went on, the relationships deepened and even Jack and Daniel developed a certain respect for one another despite what ought to have been irreconcilable differences. Teal’c grew a sense of humor and Jack actually had sensitive moments. Sam became a strong leader, but retained her femininity and never crossed the line into becoming Jane Bond. Thank goodness. I will say that the writers went overboard playing with my heart in terms of the Jack-Sam dynamic, because they became in my opinion the most frustrating “will they, won’t they?” couple in TV history, but without the satisfaction of a definite resolution in one direction or the other. The obvious affection swelled to breaking point and then... was brushed off. Unlike Captain Picard and Dr. Crusher of Star Trek: The Next Generation, whose relationship was left open for possibilities at the finale of the series, Jack and Sam just forgot about their feelings and then Jack left. Simple as that. I suppose I can give the show props for not getting soapy, at least most of the time. Sam’s relationship with Pete was not a high point for me.
One thing I would say Stargate: SG-1 did better than most shows would be able to in a ten season run, is excellent continuity. One of the most satisfying things about continuity is getting to say with a simultaneous sense of dread and anticipation “you again…” When SG-1 introduced an antagonist, it was sure as tax that he or she would be seen again in some capacity or another if they got away. While Linea, Destroyer of Worlds yielded a somewhat anti-climactic one-episode reappearance, the encounter with Fifth the Replicator brought far-reaching consequences and an unexpected tangent to the Replicator arc, spanning several episodes. Likewise a seemingly insignificant episode centered on a relationship between Daniel and an old colleage released a new Goa'uld enemy, leading into one of the most intense story arcs.
As in most sci-fi, you could never depend on someone actually being dead. Would Apophis ever die for good? Would Maybourne ever stop popping up at the worst possible time? And die? Would Kinsey ever do the world a favor and get himself assassinated? And just when I thought the team could relax a bit, having not heard from Apophis in some time, we were dealt Sokar and an Apophis encore. The Goa'uld held legendary grudges, and would never forget a grievance dealt them, be it a few seasons ago, or a few millenia ago. While certain story points that seemed like they would be monumental trailed off without too much ceremony, thinking back I can't recall a real loose end anywhere.
The fall of one Goa’uld would give rise to the next, each one strikingly unique in his, her, or its own vein of evil. I was just about to grow tired of the endless reappearing schemes of Apophis when the writers wrote in a timely and truly fitting end for the villain. Appropriately, Apophis had one of the most glorious exits of all SG-1 nemeses, and watching the fiend helplessly face his demise was just spectacular, not to mention poetic. With Apophis now out of the way, new overarching threats needed to be created that did not repeat Apophis. SG-1 came through fantastically with Osiris and his alliance of system lords, Anubis, Ba’al, and the rise to prominence of more Replicators. While more minor villains such as the insipid Nirrti or overly sensual Hathor were not even fun to hate, the dominating powers of evil became every bit as essential to the sagas as SG-1 itself, and I even had favorites among the adversaries.
Among the greater adversaries of Stargate SG-1, my favorites were the classics. Anubis, a seemingly unbeatable entity with an evil so pure that other Goa’uld considered
Anubis’ ways unspeakable, brought a supernatural element to the Goa'uld threat. As an ascended being, his powers of evil operated on a level outside the realm of reality -- a different dimension if you will, making him an especially formidable foe. Ba’al, so arrogant and yet borderline charming in his unexcitable manners and elegantly brutal mind games (such as his repeated killing and resurrection of Jack) seemed a straightforward enough Goa'uld, but he had more on his side than legions of fear-bound followers; he was cunning. Ba'al was a true strategist and tactical artist, constantly surprising. Even in the face of certain defeat, Ba’al remained maddeningly poised and unwaveringly superior in all his mannerisms. Lastly, I had to love the presence of the Replicators. Until the encounter with Fifth, the Replicators were a mindless destructive machine without a face or a heart. This in itself made the Replicators an entity that forced a new battle-mode. Fighting an enemy that does not bleed or hurt proved to be a challenge that even the superior Asgard found daunting. When the SG-1 team lands on a Replicator planet, the machines entered a new level of dangerous destroyers: they were shown to be self-aware. Soon SG-1 was not just dealing with mechanical spider-like Replicators, but they had Fifth and Repli-Carter-- a Samantha Carter replicator impostor.
In ten seasons of character development and progression, certain emotional wrenches are inevitable. There was a certain tightness in my heart as Daniel tearfully bid goodbye to Jack and departed this world in Meridian. Eyes were wiped as Sam delivered her honoring speech at Dr. Frazier’s funeral in Heroes. While I never cared for Sha’re (or the dreadful acting her character was doomed to), I couldn’t help but sympathize with Daniel as he grieved over the loss of his wife in Forever in a Day. During Jack’s captivity under Ba’al, I couldn't help but understand his caving to hopelessness with his daily death and resurrection in Abyss. And as previously mentioned, it was hard not to hope that somehow Jack and Sam would stop ignoring their feelings. Teal’c may have been the strongest of the team both physically and emotionally, but he sensitively displayed feeling torn as a warrior, father, estranged husband, and friend. While his loyalties were often at odds with one another, Teal’c proved time and time again that he was an invaluable member of the SG-1 team, saving the lives of his comrades on numerous occasions. At times he frustrated me with how determined he was to pay penance for his past as First Prime of Apophis, but Teal'c remained a sterling hero.
In time, SG-1 moved on from the predominantly Egyptian mythologies and turned its attention to Arthurian and Atlantian themes. Unfortunately, with the final defeat of the Goa’uld came the unannounced departure of Jack O’Neill to be replaced by younger and inexperienced Cameron Mitchell. After eight seasons with O’Neill at the helm, it was hard not to feel like Mitchell was a cheap substitution. He dropped onto the scene suddenly and conveniently, bringing with him a few more new characters that just didn’t quite mesh with the eight previous seasons of development. General Landry was a far departure in leadership style and personality from the straight-laced General Hammond. And then there was Vala Mal Doran who was just… a fish out of water to put it most politely. Mitchell was not a bad character, just thrust forward as the lead a little too quickly. Despite character replacements being a little disappointing, the story continued, introducing an arc that might have lasted multiple seasons with the new threat of the Ori. Most of seasons nine and ten drew on basic Arthurian legend, adding the sci-fi twist and incorporating the Ori into the mix. And a timely reappearance of old nemesis Ba’al, just in time to keep things interesting. And then, just as I thought to myself that this Ori arc with the insatiably evil Adria could set up the show for a few more seasons, it ended.
After ten seasons of tension, rising action, falling action, new enemies, old enemies, secret enemies, gains and losses, and a just a little drama within, it is hard to envision what an appropriate ending would be. Truthfully I appreciated that the universe was not saved once and for all, leaving all the SG-1 members to go on and lead a quiet life hereafter. Nor was everyone conveniently bumped off in some horribly dramatic fashion. Unending took a different, more contemplative approach to finish off the series by allowing the remaining SG-1 characters to live out their lives in a time dilation bubble, trapped in what some would consider a fate worse than death. Warriors were now caged, helpless, and unable to even die in battle. Stuck with nothing but decades of time, age and hopelessness set in as day after day of analyzing proved fruitless. Of course they get out and get to be young again and continue their missions with only one of them retaining any memory of the events. The series ends with a “business as usual” tone, and SG-1 steps through the gate for yet another adventure just before the credits roll one last time.
When Unending ended, SG-1 was over, and ten seasons worth of time were now complete. The stories were told, the battles were fought, and the book was closed. Yet thanks to the wisdom of the writers, although it was clearly the end of an era, I did not feel that it was truly the end. There were still undefeated enemies out there, and more planets in need of emancipation. The team would continue saving the universe one planet at a time, even if their escapades would no longer be available on DVD. No sooner had the Stargate activated one last time and hosted the heroes through the event horizon, I wanted to start over again. Now with the knowledge of how one thing affects the next episode to episode, I wanted to go back. Stargate SG-1 had many high points, a few low points, some fantastic comedic points, and some stirring dramatic points. Stargate SG-1 is a truly fine specimen that does justice to science fiction in all the best ways. A great show indeed.
~Special thanks to "Ecarganna" for sparking my interest so long ago during our long, nerdy sci-fi talks, "Freckles" and "Spud" for getting it started, and "Potter", "Jonface", and "Imspecial" for many, many nights of sharing the experience, as well as the friends who occasionally popped in~
Labels:
character analysis,
hero,
review,
sci-fi,
villain
Thursday, June 7, 2012
Avengers, Assemble!
Anyone who went to the theater for last year’s Captain America or Thor knew that Marvel was just getting origin stories out of the way so that The Avengers could be made. With Iron Man already well-established, a few more Marvel characters couldn’t hurt, especially considering Iron Man might have become the reigning comic book hero of the summer of 2008 had it not been for a certain Dark Knight. And now, they’re back. Fans, assemble!
If you, my reader, have read my reviews before, you know that I hone in on characters. This review will be no exception, though I promise to not devote an entire paragraph to each individual Avenger or supporting character. A few sentences each will probably suffice, since The Avengers is not a movie for character development—it is a crisis-driven action vehicle that features characters we know and don’t have to acquaint ourselves with. It saves time and leaves more of it for explosions, and let’s be honest: what more do you really want in a superhero movie?
I’ll start with Tony Stark, who doesn’t need much introduction. He remains shamelessly narcissistic, yet inexplicably likable, and ingeniously played by Robert Downey Jr. In all humility I have to admit that no matter how much I try, no one captures my thoughts on Stark more eloquently than Roger Ebert (4th paragraph of article). Moving on from the highest-grossing (and most spotlight-stealing) individual character, I will confess that I have not seen any Hulk movies, as the character and story never interested me. Therefore I must conclude with no comparison to previous interpretations that Mark Ruffalo does a decent job with Bruce Banner. Banner is awkward, but is so out of fear of himself rather than lack of social skills. To be fair, periodic transformations into a giant monster does present social difficulties. Nevertheless, when Banner is not The Hulk and not smashing things, he is an interesting enough presence. It’s fairly clear that most everyone (except Stark) has a healthy respect for Banner—agent Romanov is especially jumpy around him and often treats him like a stalled grenade that may or may not detonate at any moment. But even in his Hulk persona, he is not universally despised, and has a few good moments as the Hulk worthy of a chuckle (a certain moment with Loki comes to mind).
Thor and Captain America have a curious clash of similarity and dissention. Both men are patriotic and driven by honor and duty. While Captain America fights because he feels he has a responsibility to keep evil at bay, he would rather diplomatically negotiate first, and fight if necessary. Thor on the other hand has such a sterling sense of justice that he can hardly be dissuaded from swinging his mighty hammer at the opposition. That is not to say that Thor is hasty or unreasonable, just much more prone to dive into the action and start knocking aside whatever is in his way. Think of it this way, Captain America’s main article is his shield which is primarily a defensive piece, and Thor’s choice is a hammer which is most decidedly an offensive piece. These objects speak volumes about their bearers, so judging the characters by their weapons would not yield inaccurate results.
Nick Fury and Natasha Romanov are present, but there isn’t much to them. They both do a good job in their respective roles, and the movie does not devote itself to the worship of Scarlett Johansson’s curves, thankfully. Come to think of it, the movie made a very strange decision and tried to make Pepper Potts seem sultry. She’s only onscreen for a minute or two, but even as Stark’s main squeeze it was out of character. Besides that, someone goofed on Paltrow’s hair and makeup—she looks a little aged. One character whose history is barely alluded to, but is given almost-Avenger status is Clint Barton (otherwise known as Hawkeye). True to the usual roles of Jeremy Renner, he is intense, dark, and distinctly dangerous even as a good guy. But he is intriguing enough that you would want him on your side if you were SHIELD, as the man does not shy away from great danger.
And finally there is Loki, the premier villain of the film. Loki was introduced in Thor, so we already know as soon as his pallid face appears that he is about to wreak havoc on the weaklings of earth. Loki has come a long way since the revelation that he was not a son of Odin—he is no longer hiding behind a guise of earning father’s approval and has chosen yet another race of evil aliens to ally himself with. Loki finds our Avengers quickly enough and starts unfolding his plan without wasting any time at all. Thor may have some sentiments about Loki being his (adopted) brother, but Loki has no such loyalties. He proves this by expelling Thor from an airborne aircraft carrier in a cell, hurtling towards earth. Furthermore, he has grown insufferably superior in his entitlement—the “I am a god” complex has only gotten bigger if that’s possible. Tom Hiddleston said of his character Loki in an interview “How pleasant an experience is it to disappear into a wormhole that was created by some super-nuclear explosion of his own making? I think by the time Loki shows up he's seen a few things and has bigger things in mind than just his brother and Asgard...."
Enough about characters. This isn’t a character movie, even though there are many characters in it. By the time the movie starts, the audience is expected to already be familiar with the characters, so the movie doesn’t have to waste time on origins. Moving on, what is the Avengers really about? Action. Lots of action. The movie is made up of long and short fight sequences with humans, super-humans, small monsters, and very big monsters. Crisis after crisis command the attention and skills of our heroes, and one conflict after another ensures that they stay on their toes. Much of the non-fighting sequences are utilized to show how unlikely and complicated they are as a team. Every one of the main Avengers has his own movie to prove that he doesn’t really need a crew to save the world from the powers of evil, but they also can’t deny that this time they’re in over their heads. So they fight. They fight enemies, they fight one another, they fight enemies again, and so the cycle goes. For this being the case, it cannot be denied that the Avengers does a very clean job of sewing the special effects into the camerawork, and does not get so visually busy and overpowering as say, Transformers. Yes the visuals are big and comic-bookish, but the point is that as a viewer, you can stay on top of what’s going on and not have to stop your eyes from spinning amid all the action, explosions, blasts, crashes, and wrecks.
The writers were kind enough to throw a bone to anyone who may have been engaged in a juvenile debate over who is the best Avenger and who could beat whom in a fight. Iron Man takes on Thor. Thor fights back. There is blasting and many trees are felled in the wake of their spat. Captain American interferes and next thing you know, all three are engaged in an all-out "top this" match against one another. Thor throws his mighty hammer, Captain America throws his mighty shield, and Iron Man does what Iron Man does. It ends with all three of them lying flat on their backs, so really no one wins this one. It was still fun to watch though, because deep down, even I was wondering who was the alpha-male. My bet is for... Thor.
Action in itself would not be enjoyable in this type of movie without at least some semblance of a plot. Comic book movies in general do not demand a strong plot, only a functional one. Most of these plots fall under the same basic structure of the hero(es) using their powers to defeat evil and save Earth-- otherwise known as New York City. The Avengers does not really offer anything new on this front, as the basic structure is indeed that there is a villain who wants to enslave earth, which is not a far cry from destroying it like other villains tend to fantasize about as if they were Marvin the Martian. Act One entails the usual gathering of forces and initial conflict, propelling to the finale of Act Two, where we have our first full-blown knock-down drag-out among Avengers, as well as between Avengers and foes. It is in the finale of this section of the movie where Joss Whedon writes his signature on the piece—killing someone. This loss predictably gives the rest the necessary motivation to press on through the finale of Act Three where good and evil come head to head and attempt to pummel each other to death until one cries uncle, and the conflict subsides until the inevitable sequel (alluded to in the epilogue).
The Avengers is colorful, fun, larger-than-life, and a little ridiculous, but a heck of a lot of fun. It is exactly what one ought to expect from a summer popcorn flick. Of course it isn’t Oscar worthy or even Nolan worthy, but it doesn’t try to be, and therein lies its strength. Depth? Of course not. It is not designed to be critiqued by the Hollywood Foreign Press or the Academy of Motion Pictures. The Avengers is nothing more or less than a comic book summer blockbuster, complete with bright colors, extravagant machines, ostentatious fights, blatant disregard for realism, and sometimes choppy dialogue, all packed together into one parcel of escapism. Categorized accordingly and accepted within these guidelines, the Avengers ranks in the top achievers of its genre.
Labels:
Avengers,
character analysis,
comic book movie,
hero,
review,
sci-fi,
villain
Thursday, March 8, 2012
Doubt
At first glance, a morose drama called Doubt centered on a few nuns and a priest at a catholic school seems more like a Lifetime Original Movie than an Academy Award Best Picture contender. Yet as the story unfolds, it becomes clear that Doubt is about more than a scandal and a bitter old nun, but delves deeply into the danger of legalism, the trouble with school and church politics, and the irreparable destructive power of gossip. Although Doubt may seem straightforward enough, the simplicity of the story and its outstanding cast are its greatest strengths, inviting the viewer to assess the situation presented with minimal information, try to draw conclusions, and then doubt everything.
Doubt is carried by three strong performances and sold by one brief supporting role. Meryl Streep's sterling turn as Sister Aloysius is immaculately merciless as she steers the plot vehicle through the levels of suspicion, accusation, and doubt. From the first moment that Aloysius turns her face towards the camera to reprimand a boy for sleeping in church, the hardness in her voice and eyes pierce straight through the screen, setting the tone of her unshakably hostile piety. She stands in stark contrast to the naïve warm and fuzzy young Sister James (excellently played by Amy Adams), who bubbles over with love for students and history. While Aloysius refuses to believe anything but her own suppositions, Sister James seems ready to believe anything, completely scandalized by the idea that even a thirteen year old boy might lie to get out of class. As the conflict unfolds, Aloysius loses none of her edge, but Sister James gradually finds herself less cheery as she begins to feel the full weight of the trouble she has been part of.
Audiences expect flawless portrayals from Meryl Streep, but it takes a very strong male lead to hold his own against the iconic actress, and Philip Seymour Hoffman does this masterfully. His part is the most difficult of the characters because his purposes and motivations remain undefined throughout the entire movie. Even as the credits roll it is uncertain if Father Flynn is truly guilty or not. The movie does not seek to answer this question, so Hoffman must portray Father Flynn in such a way that either option could be true; Hoffman does this with absolutely stunning skill. He shows himself a likable priest with a sense of humor and a progressive proclivity, with just enough mystery to his character to be suspicious. He is the absolute opposite of Sister Aloysius, and their scenes together are easily the most intense as their stark differences battle ferociously. One particular scene involving the two characters talking privately, soars as the old nun screams her determination to do what is necessary to condemn the priest, even if it breaks her vows.
The genius of Doubt is in the writing. Very few movies could take a seemingly drab plot and using only dialogue, keep the viewers on the edges of their seats. While the movie deals with the possibility of an inappropriate relationship between a priest and a young male student, the subject matter is handled with such decorum and discretion that the implications would be entirely lost on younger innocent viewers. Throughout the movie, even as Aloysius hurls ugly accusations at Father Flynn, the expository language is never more explicit than merely "inappropriate relationship." The audience will never hear the words pedophile, molester, sexual abuse, or homosexual, even though these things are all dealt with as part of the central conflict of the movie.
Exquisite performances and impeccable writing are key players in creating the doubt as to whether or not Father Flynn is guilty. What is shown and discreetly not shown give enough evidence to support either view, while still not fully answering the question. Viewers that suspect he may be a lecherous pedophile will see the logic in the accusations of Sister Aloysius, while viewers who are convinced of his innocence will empathize with Sister James. All three of these characters are crucial in selling the story and forcing the viewer to not just watch attentively, but participate in the frustration, anger, suspicion, grief, and regret. While any one of the actors might have out-shined the other, they all work together to form a strong and stirring ensemble. The brief appearance of Viola Davis as Mrs. Miller functions as a cherry on top as it were, being a shining moment of emotion amidst the many complex levels that are explored throughout the course of the film.
By the time the final scene finds Aloysius breaking down and showing a faint glimmer of humanity, there is nothing left but what the title suggests, doubt. There is doubt as to whether Father Flynn got off easy for hideous actions, or was the victim of a series of traps laid by an unyielding and determined nun. There is doubt about Sister Aloysius and her methods of handling the entire situation, manipulating the facts to reach a definite end. There is doubt about Sister James and what she really saw that day that began the scandal. The final lines gasped by Aloysius deliver one last punch, leaving the viewer to draw their own conclusions, but also leaving that feeling that whatever side the viewer has decided on, they ought to doubt their perceptions.
Tuesday, March 6, 2012
Sherlock Holmes A Game of Shadows
When an old and often redone story hits mega-success the way that Sherlock Holmes did in 2009, a sequel is inevitable. And just as every sequel must top the success of its predecessor, so must it also engage viewers in a plot that will without a doubt involve some sort of world-affecting conflict. Such is the case with the explosive A Game of Shadows where Holmes and Watson reunite (albeit reluctantly for Watson) for another adventure of narrow escapes and near-death experiences.
A Game of Shadows picks up very closely where the first film left off, with Watson on the brink of marriage and Holmes on the trail of yet another foul fiend. The first film's closing lines led into the introduction of the infamous professor Moriarty, who finally appears here in the second film. A Game of Shadows is predominantly a stand-alone movie rather than a sequel, fleshing out its own plot with very few tie-ins to the first movie. Most audiences familiar with Holmes are equally aware of his arch-nemesis Moriarty, therefore the fact that the professor makes his debut in A Game of Shadows is satisfying and strategic. In some strange way it had a certain Dark Knight quality to it, in that the filmmakers deliberately did not introduce the most famous enemy to the protagonist until the second movie.
The stronger points of the first Sherlock Holmes movie are repeated in A Game of Shadows. Part of what made the first movie so enjoyable was the witty chemistry between Jude Law and Robert Downey Jr., who faithfully reprise their roles here. Watson remains the reluctant best friend to Holmes, but he is neither useless nor perfect. He is unfailingly faithful to his less than considerate friend, but is human enough to vocalize his justified complaints about Holmes' tactics-- most notably the complete ruin of his bachelor party and honeymoon. Holmes remains characteristically ignorant of everyone else's needs and is relentlessly focused on the case at hand. Though considering the stakes of the case at hand one could hardly blame him.
Suffice to say that Robert Downey Jr.'s quirky interpretation of the classic sleuth remains solid, and Jude Law as Watson continues to deliver. It is the newcomers that garner the most attention-worthy performances here. The most interesting newcomer is also fairly fresh to the Hollywood scene in general. Coming from her success in the European film The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Noomi Rapace brings to A Game of Shadows an intriguing female supporting role. Not only is her role as a gypsy Madame Sim creative, her motives are believable and sympathetic, and her lifestyle and background are consistent with her self-defense skills. Another newcomer is none other than celebrated British comedian Stephen Fry as Holmes' brother Mycroft. Fry's function in the movie is not necessarily needless, but his nude scene is.
The catalyst to any good movie is a solid villain. As Professor James Moriarty, Jared Harris takes the reins of one of literature's most iconic antagonists, and steers the character to new levels. In examining Harris as Moriarty it is extremely difficult to allow his interpretation of the character to stand apart from the many predecessors that have also been the professor. All these things aside however, it cannot be denied that Harris unquestionably possesses the grace and charm to be Moriarty. True to the spirit of the character, however evil his actions are, he cannot be convinced of his wrongdoings or asked to question the ethical dilemma of sacrificing a few for the good of many. He accurately communicates almost mad genius, while still maintaining a certain degree of charisma and control, even as he swings a skewered Holmes from a meat hook. Harris' Moriarty is edgy, but faithful to the books. He is brilliant, motivated, driven, arrogant, and retains his aristocratic manners at all times.
Moving to the film itself, A Game of Shadows has to be accepted at a specific level in order to be enjoyed or appreciated. It should not be looked at as a period drama, an action movie, or a comedy, but an even combination of all three. The quality of the story falls short of greatness, but as pure entertainment it succeeds well. While the characters are enjoyable to watch, the movie is not a character movie, as it focuses more on circumstances and action sequences than character development, and plays out more like a comic book movie than anything else. People (like me) that enjoy digging beneath the surface will not find much in A Game of Shadows, which leads me to conclude that it therefore must be taken at surface value or left alone altogether. As a story, A Game of Shadows has enough twists and turns to be interesting, but it would be generous to call any of these devices unpredictable or surprising.
When the original Sherlock Holmes movie was released, speculation abounded as to the real nature of the relationship between Holmes and Watson-- namely, gay or nay? Such speculation is unfounded by any obvious content in either film, but it would seem that A Game of Shadows attempts to either derail or fuel the speculation by completely overdoing the implications. Holmes, for example, refers to Watson as his partner on more than one occasion, causing Watson to cringe. Holmes and Watson are only partners as concerns their cooperative efforts on solving cases, but the film-makers are clearly cognizant of how modern audiences will attempt to perceive the relationship, so rather than eliminating the suggestion altogether, they overplay it. This is especially evident when Holmes is forced to botch Watson’s honeymoon in order to save the couple’s lives. Once Mrs. Watson is removed from the honeymoon car, the next scenes find Watson furiously tearing at Holmes’ clothing as they scuffle on the floor of the train car, with Holmes is dressed as a woman. It is by no means a scene that suggests any sort of homoerotic connection, but it is no accident on the part of the director to depict Holmes as an unwanted substitute for Mrs. Watson.
As previously mentioned, A Game of Shadows must be taken at face value in order to be enjoyed. While the continual sequences of slow-motion are undoubtedly creative, they do get a bit old after a while. Sometimes this device works extremely well and other times seems like unnecessary pomp. Under of all the glitzy camerawork and grand explosions is an interesting enough story with some good laughs along the way and a few good twists. The characters have believable motives, and even Moriarty’s grand scheme to topple the delicate balance of the world is not implausible, but A Game of Shadows is not a realistic movie and it is not meant to be. Sherlock Holmes’ newest adventure is altogether enjoyable, succeeding as a fairly decent combination of action and comedy.
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Lessons Learned from Harry Potter
It takes a great deal of courage to stand up to your enemies, but a great deal more to stand up to your friends. It does not do to dwell in dreams and forget to live.
It is not our abilities that determine who we truly are, it is our choices.
Events will occur that will fail to make sense in the here and now, but nothing is coincidental or meaningless.
Help will always be given to those who ask for it.
Looks can be deceiving (Snape, Neville, Umbridge, Lockhart, Moody, need I go on?)
"It is important to fight, and fight again, and keep fighting, for only then can evil be kept at bay, though never quite eradicated."
"Do not pity the dead. Pity the living, and above all, those who live without love."
Time does not heal all wounds. Ahem, Snape.
Keep your friends by you. Harry would not have survived year one, let alone the rest of his adventures without loyal friends.
Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also. This is probably the most prominent theme of the entire series, stated in book seven. Will Harry treasure power, fame, or will it be loving others no matter the cost and seeking to overcome evil?
The capacity to love more than the extent of one's abilities determine the capacity for greatness, as shown by Neville Longbottom.
Loyal friends are worth more than popular and powerful ones. Would Crabbe take a knife for Draco the way Dobby does for Harry? I think not. Equal treatment of those deemed "lesser" reaps great benefits, but prejudice and condescension reap hard consequences. Harry treated Dobby as an equal and Dobby in return lays down his life for his friend. Kreacher and Griphook were treated with disdain, therefore those who treated them unfairly greatly regret it later.
Never underestimate the young. Voldemort shouldn't have.
Never underestimate the elderly. Professor McGonagall! Book readers: Neville's gran.
You are never really alone in your battles. Harry may have made extreme sacrifices, but he is not the only one affected by the conflict that he is central to (Hermoine erasing herself from her own parents' memories, the many character casualties at the battle of Hogwarts, etc.)
Don't always believe what you read. Rita Skeeter clearly could not be trusted to print the truth, or at least not without a sharp angle on it.
All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing. And don't trust the government to be the ones to do something. Minister for Magic Cornelius Fudge (and his successor) could not be trusted to accept the truth or act on it and as a result the magical world falls into an era of darkness and fear.
Just because someone is on your side doesn't necessarily mean they should always be listened to. Sorry Sirius.
Never become between a mother and her child. Lord Voldemort tried that and spent the better part of fourteen years as a diminished stump of a being. Bellatrix Lastrange made the same mistake and it was not only the last thing she ever did, but she created a situation bad enough to make Molly Weasley spout one of the best lines in the entire series.
Fear is one of the greatest and most crippling weapons. For proof of that, look at the Ministry of Magic. When it becomes clear that Lord Voldemort has indeed returned, rather tha
n fighting against him, they vilify Harry and all those associated with him.
n fighting against him, they vilify Harry and all those associated with him. Book smarts are good to have, but you have to get out of the library for them to do you any good. Hermoine learns this after the troll incident.
Some things are simply worth waiting for.
What goes around comes around. Sometimes. Peter Pettigrew gets his comeuppance, but Delores Umbridge not so much. Or the Malfoys. Okay, what goes around doesn't always come back around.
And finally, when good goes against evil, there is no sitting on the sidelines. All will be affected one way or another, so choose your side.
Labels:
character analysis,
Harry Potter,
hero,
review,
villain
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














